Graph RAG prompts & synthesis: Sovereign origination context
High-signal question templates for continuous Graph RAG evaluation, plus synthesized answers aligned to the HoloScript runtime (dual digest semantics, optional x402 tiers, Film3D telemetry). Use this to score retrieval and to catch overclaims in generated prose.
Related: packages/studio/docs/SOVEREIGN_ORIGINATION_STACK.md, packages/studio/docs/walkthrough.md, .ai-ecosystem futurist / COMPRESS docs.
Accuracy guardrails (read before scoring answers)
GistPublicationManifestV0carries two digest concepts:provenance_semiring_digest(v0sha256_canonical_v0, includes optionalxr_metricsin the canonical payload) and optionaltropical_semiring_digest(3×3 matrix from params). They are layered, not replacements; v0 SHA is not “deprecated” by tropical.- x402 is optional in the type and default path; deployments may set
GIST_MANIFEST_REQUIRE_X402so the gist-manifest route returns 402 without a receipt. binds_composition_to_historyand similar names are logical edges unless your graph schema defines them explicitly in code.
1. Sovereign origination & provenance core
Q1: Trace the path from SovereignUserAgent → HoloScriptGraph → ProvenanceSemiring → PublishToCitadelOrMarket. What is the maturity of binds_composition_to_history?
Synthesis: In code, composition flows through Studio or headless execution: executeStudioGraph / bridge → results may include previewHoloScript from the node-graph preview path (nodeGraphPlayPreview / execution bridge). Publication is buildGistPublicationManifest (and POST /api/publication/gist-manifest), optionally with tropicalSemiringDigest supplied from computeTropicalSemiringDigest(doc) in packages/crdt-spatial/src/legalDocumentCrdt.ts, which folds Loro’s version vector into a fixed 3×3 matrix (heuristic fingerprint, not full merge-event tropical algebra over arbitrary ops).
Maturity: The named edge binds_composition_to_history should be treated as a conceptual label unless your schema materializes it. Algebraic maturity is partial: tropical matrix + v0 SHA coexist; formal homomorphism from every CRDT merge to semiring operations is not claimed by the current implementation.
Q2: Compare conceptual ProvenanceSemiring to actual GistPublicationManifestV0 fields. What is the delta?
Synthesis: The manifest exposes provenance_semiring_digest (sha256_canonical_v0) and optional tropical_semiring_digest. The “delta” from a purely conceptual semiring paper is closed for shipping artifacts in the sense that both binding (v0 SHA) and optional matrix slots exist; the research delta remains: proving that the matrix equals a specified min-plus/max-plus merge law over audit-relevant operations.
Q3: Show nodes/edges from CRDT merge to x402 / Base L2.
Synthesis (executable path):Loro state → doc.version().toJSON() (and related APIs) → computeTropicalSemiringDigest(doc) (crdt-spatial) → optional pass into buildGistPublicationManifest({ tropicalSemiringDigest, … }) → tropical_semiring_digest + optional x402_receipt on GistPublicationManifestV0 → publish via /api/publication/gist-manifest (and human commit of JSON as needed).
Gap: Base L2 transaction anchoring is not automatically wired; timestamps in receipts are ISO-level unless your facilitator pipeline fills chain-specific fields. Treat “BaseL2Timestamp” as product/integrator scope unless code explicitly binds a rollup.
2. Film3D XR & physical grounding
Q4: Occlusion / gaze metrics vs provenance state vector?
Synthesis: Film3dXrMetricsBridge (with throttled sampling / worker relay) feeds hitTestCount, occlusionProofAcquired, and related fields into xr_metrics on the manifest path. By default these metrics do not write back into the Loro document’s merge history. They do affect provenance_semiring_digest (v0) when xr_metrics is included in buildGistPublicationManifest. They do not by themselves change computeTropicalSemiringDigest unless application code merges them into that computation.
Net: Passive / sidecar relative to CRDT ticks; not sidecar to the v0 digest when xr_metrics is present.
Q5: Director end-to-end path in WebXR; gaps?
Synthesis: NodeGraphPanel → Run XR toggles WebXRViewer with previewHoloScript when available → session + Film3dXrMetricsBridge → manifest build may attach xr_metrics.
Gap: Proves device/session signals and bundling into manifest metadata; it does not prove that generated HoloScript was parametrically driven by occlusion/gaze unless the compiler path consumes those signals.
3. Economic sovereignty & adoption
Q6: Is x402 optional or mandatory? Trace the effect.
Synthesis: x402_receipt is optional on the manifest type. Deployment policy: when GIST_MANIFEST_REQUIRE_X402 is set, the gist-manifest route can reject requests without a non-empty receipt (HTTP 402). Narratives about “weak economy door” should acknowledge tiered enforcement, not only type-level optionality.
Q7: Top single points of failure for non-founder sovereign proof?
Synthesis (risk framing, not bug list):
- XR telemetry without hardware attestation → spoofable
xr_metricsin principle. - Optional economic anchor when policy does not require x402.
- Identity binding: tropical matrix from Loro peers is not a substitute for DID / wallet linkage unless integrated elsewhere.
4. Strategic & forward-looking
Q8: Smallest changes to make Film3D story “more executable” (impact / effort)?
- High impact / policy: Enforce x402 on chosen tiers via
GIST_MANIFEST_REQUIRE_X402(and product UX), not necessarily by throwing insidebuildGistPublicationManifestfor every caller. - High impact / medium effort: Persist
xr_metrics(or summaries) into a Loro map during session/sync if you need causal binding to CRDT ticks. - Medium / high effort: Real L2 anchoring on gist finalize via your payment / facilitator stack.
Q9: Three discrepancies between “strong evidentiary” vision and runtime?
Synthesis:
- Algebra vs cryptography: Matrix + SHA bind artifacts; they do not alone constitute legal inventorship or chain-of-custody without process and counsel.
- Proxies vs platform:
stdio-proxyfilters child env; the host OS and container story remain part of the trust boundary. - Observation vs generation: WebXR can observe capabilities; proving semantic use in generated output needs explicit pipeline hooks.
Q10: Emergent relationships from embeddings?
Synthesis: Treat max-plus / commutative narratives as threat-model hypotheses until you specify adversaries, merge policies, and conflict visibility in Loro. “Provenance dominance” via spam is not established as a theorem from the current code paths alone—flag for red-team and formalization, not as fact.
Maintenance
When runtime behavior changes (new Loro hooks, new manifest fields, new env flags), update Accuracy guardrails and the affected Q&A blocks so Graph RAG evaluators do not reward stale prose.